Quote:
Davin wrote
No, it doesn't. Even over an infinite amount of time with in an infinite amount of universes, there can never be a square circle. It's probably not even possible for such a being to exist.
Is this your attempt at a ridiculously silly faulty dilemma? Either we think that there is a super powerful entity or we think that humans are the most powerful beings in existence? No room for anything else? For say that there are beings that are a bit more powerful than humans?
|
Davin you have no evidence which points to the impossibility of a very strong, much stronger than human, alien entity. Humans are "stronger" now than they were thousands of years ago because of acquired knowledge and development of science - so we know that beings of a species tend to get "stronger" over time. There are no square circles here.
The debate between us is as to just how strong an alien entity can potentially be. Indeed, there may be a threshold maximum level - beyond which you square circle argument becomes valid. However what is this maximum threshold. ?
If an alien being can (or has) evolved to be able to do some not that difficult acts (such as change water to wine, bring dead people or animals back to life, multiply matter - bread etc. levitate or walk on water ) then a "God" like being indeed exists - at least by Biblical or Quranic standards.
Do you think that humans through scientific development in the future will never be able to do the above? That is what you must believe to make your square circle analogy hold water.